Existence vs. Substance of an Argument

Introduction

Many people who have doubts or waswasah ask me, “How can I deal with arguments people make, because I cannot feel secure or settled without hearing a response?”

Because of this, they are forced to watch debates or ask people questions to even the most trivial arguments for every topic, whether that is the truth of Islam itself or whether certain scholars are reliable or unreliable.

This short article is meant to deal with this disease of the heart.

Origin of the Disease

Like all waswasah, this disease originates in letting Shaitan have power over your thoughts. That is caused by loneliness and not praying in the masjid, not praying prayers on time, not doing azkar and seeking protection in Allah, and not reciting Quran regularly.

However, this disease, unlike other types of waswasah, also originates in online debate culture which makes arguments seem like entertainment and a boxing match rather than something you understand and analyze. Those who watch debates outsource arguments to the debators and simply watch them respond and respond back to each other for the sake of satisfaction and entertainment.

When they do this, they trick their mind into thinking the existence of the argument is the argument itself, as if every argument requires a response before they can consider its strength.

Strength of Arguments

Arguments can be entirely certain, strong, mediocre, weak, or entirely useless. There is an entire spectrum. You do not need someone to tell you whether an argument is bad or not. In fact, the whole point of arguments is that they are words meant to convince you. You must ask yourself, is this argument very convincing after all that I know?

That is why you can find, if you search on YouTube or Google, hours upon hours of arguments claiming the earth is flat. The existence of those arguments does not make them strong. Even there being a hundred arguments does not make their view strong. If you came across any of them, you would easily dismiss them by saying you are certain the earth is round because of what you understand.

The same applies to arguments against Islam or, if you find them, refutations of scholars. Their existence does not make them strong. Even there being a hundred does not make them strong. The only thing that can make them strong is their substance, and the substance requires critical understanding and analysis.

What You Don’t Understand Can’t Hurt You

Some people say: I heard this argument. I do not know if it is strong or weak, so I want a response or at least an argument to show it is weak.

The answer is: If you hear an argument but cannot understand whether it is strong or weak, that means you have not understood the argument. As such, the argument does not matter at all. What matters to you is only what you understand, not what you do not understand.

Imagine a man tells you, “I have proof inside this black briefcase that Islam is false, but you cannot ever open the briefcase.”

Will you care? Of course not! Who cares what is inside a black briefcase!? Until the argument is presented to you, what does it matter? Why would you take this random man at his word that he has proof?

In the same way, if a man presents an argument to you but you cannot determine whether it is strong or weak, you have essentially not understood the argument. As such, it is no different to being in a briefcase, at least until you understand it enough to tell whether it is strong or weak.

Someone might say: Don’t I have a logical or rational duty to know the arguments against Islam or X?

The answer is: Allah says ⟪Allah does not charge a soul except what is within its capacity.⟫ You only have a duty to understand what is within your intellectual level. It is not your duty to understand the arguments of people whose arguments do not even comprehend to your mind. If you had a duty for that, every person would be forced to become either an expert anti-Islam apologist or an expert Islamic scholar.

Obviously, that is not every person’s duty. If an argument is above your paygrade, it is not for you to care about. You can do your best to know what you can understand within your ability.

Being Affected Is Not Understanding

Some people say: Sometimes, I hear an argument and it affects me a lot. I feel it is strong. Does that not mean I should look for a response?

The answer is: You only feel affected by the argument because your mind has become used to the game of debate and back-and-forth. In reality, however, it is clear you do not understand the argument much if this happens repeatedly and a response helps you.

If the arguments were truly weak, you would not need a response to know it is weak. The oscillating effect in your mind along with the back-and-forth is evidence that you do not truly understand either side’s arguments. You are simply enjoying the debate.

When this is the case, you should understand that the argument does not matter since you do not understand it and focus on what you understand. Seek refuge from Shaitan, pray in the masjid, and do regular azkar.

And say the following dua regularly:

رَبَّنَا لَا تُزِغْ قُلُوبَنَا بَعْدَ إِذْ هَدَيْتَنَا وَهَبْ لَنَا مِنْ لَدُنْكَ رَحْمَةً إِنَّكَ أَنْتَ الْوَهَّابُ
“Our Lord, let not our hearts deviate after You have guided us and grant us from Yourself mercy. Indeed, You are the Bestower.

Quran 3:8

Fearing Ignorance

If there is a particular subject that truly bothers you but you are able to ignore riffraff in other subjects, then it is possibly a sign that you should study that subject properly from the Islamic perspective to understand it.

A large source of fear is ignorance. When I was young, I used to watch videos by some anti-Islam apologist who used to quote random Arabic texts to show Islam is immoral or evil. I was truly afraid of him, because I did not know how to read Arabic myself to understand those texts wholistically and contextually.

So, ignorance can lead to fear and doubt.

The best cure for that is acquiring proper knowledge. However, acquiring knowledge is not the same as getting a response to each individual argument. Learning Arabic so that you are more confident in general is different from getting someone to respond to a specific claim by an anti-Islam apologist.

It may also be necessary to study deeply and properly the Islamic perspective of why we believe in Islam in the first place. What proof do we have? What arguments do we make? If you understand why we are certain of Islam, random arguments will not sway you much. A good start is my article: Why Should We Believe in Islam?

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top